mediaeyefilm
November continued: Harry Potter & The Goblet of Fire | Stoned | Mrs Henderson Presents
Home
January 06: Walk The Line | Shopgirl | A Cock and Bull Story | Memoirs Of A Geisha
Forthcoming: Syriana
December 05: The Producers
November: Kiss Kiss Bang Bang | The Constant Gardener
November continued: Harry Potter & The Goblet of Fire | Stoned | Mrs Henderson Presents
October: The Brothers Grimm | Tim Burton's 'Corpse Bride' | Lord Of War
September: Howl's Moving Castle | Goal! | On a Clear Day | Cinderella Man
August 2005 - Further Reviews: Red Eye | Bewitched
August: Asylum | The Island | Me And You And Everyone We Know | Green Street | The Skeleton Key
July: Fantastic Four | War Of The Worlds | Festival | Overnight | Batman Begins
June: Undertow | We Don't Live Here Anymore | The League of Gentlemen's Apocalypse | Sin City
April/May: Star Wars III | Millions | Strings | Kingdom Of Heaven | The Interpreter
March: The Ring Two | Be Cool | Maria Full Of Grace | Les Choristes (The Chorus)
Forthcoming:
February 2005: The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou | In Good Company
January 2005: Million Dollar Baby | Oceans Twelve
December: Vera Drake | The Merchant Of Venice
Nov: The Incredibles | BJ The Edge of Reason | The Manchurian Candidate | Birth | I Heart Huckabees
October: Finding Neverland | Alien vs Predator | Alfie
September: Wimbledon | The Life and Death of Peter Sellers | Dead Man's Shoes
September (more): Collateral | Exorcist: The Beginning | Ae Fond Kiss | Open Water
August: The Chronicles of Riddick | Catwoman | Spartan | The Terminal
August - more reviews: The Village | The Bourne Supremacy
July - I, Robot | The Stepford Wives | Fahrenheit 9/11 | Twisted
June: Godsend | The Ladykillers | Shrek 2 | Freeze Frame | Confidences Trop Intimes
May: The Day After Tomorrow | Troy
May: I'll Sleep When I'm Dead | The Football Factory | Van Helsing | The Company | Shattered Glass
April Film of the Month: Kill Bill Vol. 2
Guest Reviewer Page: Alternative takes by exceptional new writers
April Releases: The Cat In The Hat | Capturing The Friedmans | Monster
March Releases: Starsky & Hutch | Northfork
The Passion of the Christ
Movie Masterworks: Glengarry Glen Ross
Great Lost Movies: Waiting For Guffman
New on Screen: Something's Gotta Give | Big Fish | Lost In Translation
New Releases: Feb/March 2004 - Elephant | 21 Grams | House of Sand and Fog
January 2004: Reviews inc. A Mighty Wind/Runaway Jury/The Last Samurai/Dogville/Cold Mountain
Reviews: Master and Commander
Reviews: Love Actually | Matrix Revolutions | The Mother | Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Hollywood Educates!
Reviews: Seabiscuit | In The Cut | Mystic River | Down With Love | LXG
Kill Bill
Great Lost Movies: Wonderwall
Great Lost Movies: David Lynch's "Hotel Room"
Back Catalogue: Reviews 1
Back Catalogue: Reviews 2
Back Catalogue: Reviews 3
Back Catalogue: Reviews 4
Back Catalogue: Reviews 5
Back Catalogue: Reviews 6
Back Catalogue: Reviews 7
Back Catalogue: Reviews 8
Back Catalogue: Reviews 9
Celluloid Hot!
Wide, Pan and Scan
The Great Films - Visconti's "Death In Venice"
Forgotten Classics 1 - The Magic Christian
Forgotten Classics 2 - The Rebel
Forgotten Classics 3 - Being There
The One That Got Away

Harry Potter and The Goblet Of Fire

potter.jpg

Directed by Mike Newell
Cast: Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, Emma Watson, Robbie Coltrane, Ralph Fiennes

Harry Potter has hit the stormy patch known as adolescence, and so has the film series carrying his name. "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire," adapted by screenwriter Steven Kloves from the fourth book in the series by J.K. Rowling, is like an adolescent itself: moody, erratic and hard to understand.

There are secret-handshake-like leaps of logic that fans will follow but that others may interpret as a failure of dramatic clarity, continuity and organisation. Some of the dialogue sounds mumbled and certain early scenes seem dimly lit, while old characters are not reintroduced, they just reappear, and new ones feel rushed onto the screen.

Mike Newell, director of "Donnie Brasco" and "Four Weddings and a Funeral," has replaced the emotional intimacy of the last film, by Alfonso Cuarón, with a "The Lord of the Rings"- and "Star Wars"-caliber spectacle. And despite the whopping 157-minute running time - the second-longest of the four "Harry Potter" films so far - the narrative often feels haunted by what is not there. It's as if the reassuring details and minutiae upon which the series is built have become dwarfed by the long, dark shadow of the young wizard's evil nemesis, Voldemort, concealed for the past 13 years, and who here takes foul form and deadly substance.

In this context, "Goblet of Fire" serves its transitional purpose. Eight years after the first book was published in Britain and four years since the first film was released worldwide, "Harry Potter" is less an upstart phenomenon than a maturing franchise whose benign fantasy elements are hardening into place to meet a rising menace.

But there is still some subtle and unexpected levity, and puberty shows itself as being common to wizards and Muggles alike. There are meaningful glances galore, and hormones prove as powerful as any spell. Even Hagrid gets some action. At one point, the giggling ghost of Moaning Myrtle takes a bubble bath with Harry. Harry's freckled friend Ron Weasley, played by Rupert Grint, adds a new epithet to his usual refrain of "bloody hell," and although Emma Watson's Hermione Granger is smitten by a visiting hunk, she and Ron argue like they were meant for each other.

Harry, played by Daniel Radcliffe, is still his usual tousle-haired, bespectacled self, and his fate is again being stage-managed by forces beyond his control.

"Goblet of Fire" opens with what appears to be a massacre, without really exploring or explaining it. But it does cast an ominous pall over the Triwizard Cup competition that follows, especially since Harry, who under the rules is too young to compete, is mysteriously included among the contestants anyway. As he clears each obstacle, it is increasingly apparent the game is being manipulated by Voldemort's forces, but toward what end is the film's great mystery.

One of the recurring strengths of the franchise has been casting formidable adult actors - including Alan Rickman, Maggie Smith and Michael Gambon as the wizened Dumbledore who, though authoritative, doesn't have the same regal bearing of the late Richard Harris - to lend a gravity that the less mature performers may not possess.

Joining them in "Goblet of Fire" are Brendan Gleeson, as the battle-scarred new teacher at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, whose glass eye wildly rolls in its socket, and Ralph Fiennes, whose deformed Voldemort instantly joins the roster of classic movie villains.

"Goblet of Fire" is digitally majestic; winged horses pull a coach across the sky, a sunken ship majestically rises to the surface, the spiked tail of a swooping, fire-breathing dragon knocks masonry off Hogwarts' spires, and a Quidditch contest takes on Champions League football proportions.

Glendale native Theresa Corrao, a graduate of Nicolet High School and the University of Wisconsin-Madison, reprises the job of visual effects producer that she performed on the previous two "Potter" films. But the final challenge faced by Harry and the Triwizard contestants, of a dense and deadly labyrinth, also serves as a metaphor for a franchise that leaves its characters and fans standing at the entrance of a terrible and inevitable unknown.

Stoned

stoned.jpg

Director: Stephen Woolley
Cast: Leo Gregory, Paddy Considine, David Morrissey, Monet Mazur, Amelia Warner, Tuva Novotny, Ben Whishaw, Luke de Woolfson, James D White, David Walliams, Will Adamsdale, Nathalie Cox

Woolley has produced some of the finest British films made over the past two decades, so it's not surprising that he finally turns to directing. But despite some strong acting and a groovy 60s vibe, his film is simply a mess.

As the Rolling Stones grow in popularity, founding member Brian Jones (Gregory) descends into artistic excess and drug abuse. His manager (Morrissey) hires builder Frank (Considine) to work on Brian's sprawling manor, and the two men become good friends. Or maybe they're addicted to each other. Prior to Brian being found dead in his swimming pool, he's alienated his bandmates (Whishaw's Keith Richards, de Woolfson's Mick Jagger, White's Charlie Watts), his girlfriend Anita Pallenberg (Mazur) and pretty much everyone around him.

The film is assembled as a swirling eddy of encounters and flashbacks, awkwardly labelled with non-sequential dates. We never quite know where or when any given scene is taking place, certainly there's no sense of narrative context. The scenes are beautiful to look at, and often dramatically strong, but without an overriding through-line, they feel like unrelated short films featuring the same cast.

The cast is superb, but only Considine has a proper character to work with; Frank's an intriguing bundle of hopes and insecurities, plus elusive dark demons. This is really his story, not Brian's. And while Gregory has some excellent moments, he struggles to emerge from the drugged-out wooziness, especially with those cheap-looking wigs. Of the remaining cast, only Mazur and Morrissey get interesting roles, although we never know much about them. The rest barely register at all.

As a director, Woolley has some nice touches, including a striking opening nod to Sunset Boulevard, varying the film stock, and capturing the raw eccentricity of a rock star lifestyle. But he's obviously limited by copyright issues from including any Stones music or focussing on the band's own story. Also, the film is so infuriatingly jumbled that it's virtually impossible to follow. Not to mention the relentless homophobia and a series of weak epilogues. Stylish but almost unwatchable.

Mrs Henderson Presents

Directed by: Stephen Frears
Cast: Judi Dench, Bob Hoskins, Kelly Reilly, Christopher Guest, Will Young

Judi Dench should be protected in some way, by a preservation order or one of those little fences that stop deer eating young trees. Like Morgan Freeman, she brings with her an air of authority - watching her you relax, knowing that you're going to be in good hands.

Mrs Henderson Presents is the semi-true story of Laura Henderson (Dench). A wealthy widow, Mrs Henderson has lived a pampered life, but now that her husband is dead, she needs something to do. A friend suggests collecting diamonds, or taking a lover, but Mrs Henderson goes one better, she buys a derelict old theatre in Soho, and sets about refurbishing it. As she doesn't know anything about running a theatre, she hires Vivian Van Damm (Hoskins) to do it for her.

Van Damm is an old pro, and he suggests running continuous revues as a mark of difference. It works, and the Windmill's "Revuedeville" is initially a huge success. However, imitiation being the sincerest form of flattery and all that, other theatres soon follow suit, and in the search for innovation Mrs Henderson suggests they try nudes on stage. All in the best possible taste, of course, and her society connections help her to pull it off. The tableaux are a sensation and, as war approaches, also something of a comfort for the young troops preparing for battle on the western front.

But with bombs falling on London, the government threatens to close the theatre, and Mrs Henderson must fight tooth and nail to keep her precious theatre open.

A light and sunny film, Mrs Henderson Presents begins with a death. Judi Dench is all stiff upper lip and graciousness at the funeral and can only give vent to her grief in the most private of places - she rows out into the middle of a river and howls, only to stop as a rowing crew go past. This is the world of Mrs Henderson. A world where private feelings are private and even very old friends and colleagues call each other by title and surname. Mrs Henderson herself gets away with not doing a lot of these things because she is rich and well-connected, but she knows that breaking down at her husband's funeral is simply not done.

There's a surprising amount of death in the film - set as it is in the early days of the Second World War, and haunted by the memories of the first. Mrs Henderson only wants to entertain, to make people happy, but in her eagerness to do so she sometimes causes a great deal of pain. When she tries to be a mother to the girls at the theatre, especially Maureen (Reilly), it goes disastrously wrong. Hoskin, Van Damm is actually much closer to the girls, partly because he's there with them, day in and day out, and it's he who really keeps them going. The film pays tribute to the British spirit of the blitz. The intrepid Mrs H is always up on the rooftops during some of the most severe raids, and its she who is determined that the theatre should never be closed.

But its also very funny, sweet and charming, with Dench and Hoskins clearly enjoying themselves hugely. Always a pleasure to watch, they allow the young cast their moments in the spotlight, and Kelly Reilly in particular shines.

It's a good story, well told and well acted, and the kind of film, like Calendar Girls, that you could enjoy with your granny. Will Young is actually terrific in this, his screen debut - although he mostly sings and dances in true music hall style while Judi and Bob - and Kelly Reilly - run off with the acting honours.